City considering third-party management agreement for Mansfield Theater, Civic Center event spaces

City Commissioners will consider during their Nov. 17 meeting whether to contract out management of the Mansfield Theater and Civic Center event spaces to a third-party vendor.

The financial health of the event spaces has long been a struggle for the city, which has assigned minimal staff and resources for repairs to those areas.

City staff are recommending that commissioners approve an agreement with VenuWorks, an Iowa-based company, that would start Jan. 1 and run for five years initially.

Under the agreement, VenuWorks would provide venue management, booking, marketing, ticketing, event services and food and beverage operations.

“Really magical:” Great Falls Symphony Orchestra, Symphonic Choir perform Sunday

The proposal grew out of a years-long effort to determine what the city’s event facilities and services needed to be successful.

In September 2025, commissioners approved a $96,447 contract with TheatreDNA for a facilities utilization and feasibility study.

Staff recommended the agreement with TheatreDNA after receiving six responses to the request for proposals it issued in June to assess usage, physical condition, financial performance and long-term viability of the public facilities, and to develop strategic recommendations that enhance their value to the community.

The public facilities reviewed include the Mansfield Convention Center, Mansfield Theater, city commission chambers, the former Children’s Museum building and other public meeting and event spaces.

City surveying public on Civic Center events and entertainment as part of facilities utilization study

In April and May, TheatreDNA presented its report during commission work sessions.

In May, representatives of the Great Falls Symphony and city’s Mansfield advisory board said the report contained no surprises.

Gordon Johnson, former symphony music director and conductor, said it “revealed nothing that has not been reported by its current users.”

Benton Delinger of TheatreDNA told commissioners in May that the city needed a capital improvement strategy to get the facility up to snuff, which was likely a five-year plan.

City approves contract for public facilities feasibility study [2025]

Under the city’s proposed management agreement with VenuWorks, “no immediate capital improvements or new capital funding are planned as part of this transition. The proposed agreement provides that when the operating account has cumulative revenue exceeding six months of base management fees, the excess will be distributed to the city for capital infrastructure needs within the venue spaces. Building that revenue will take time and should not be viewed as an
immediate source of funding for improvements. The agreement does not eliminate the need for city
financial support; future budgets will need to account for operating results and facility needs,” according to the staff report.

In May, TheatreDNA said the city could keep managing the Mansfield and event spaces with city staff, but reinvent its structure, retaining full control, but the city would have to take some risks to bring in shows and hire artists. That would require investing in staff.

City approves final payment for Mansfield seat replacement project

The other option was to hire a third party, which could have higher rental rates for locals without an early agreement.

TheatreDNA staff said the city is in a key spot for routing and they spoke to promoters who were excited about the Mansfield Theater and would prefer to book directly with the city, but that would require staff, marketing and equipment up to modern show standards.

Delinger said they found the city didn’t have a clear set of metrics to evaluate performance of the venues or associated financials. He recommended that city officials take that to heart and develop a way to annually analyze what’s working and what’s not.

Facing shortfall for Mansfield theater projects, staff looking to private donors [2025]

In May, City Manager Greg Doyon said part of the discussion is “what do we want to be” and that the city has “been trying to limp the event portion of our services along…we haven’t given the existing staff the resources” to do what’s being ask of them.

The city has made no capital investment in the theater, making it less attractive and minimizing support.

Doyon said the city previously had an active Mansfield advisory board, but they got tired of not being able to make change since they lacked authority and the city is “very risk averse.”

Current Mansfield advisory board members have been asking questions about their role to city officials for months and asking for more information to help meaningfully contribute to the discussion, with little response from the city, according to several members.

Children’s Museum closing current location while continuing search for new home [2024]

Doyon said in May that to make the theater and event spaces work, “your business model is going ot have to change pretty dramatically in order to make that happen.”

Commissioner Rick Tryon said in May that the current model wasn’t workable and asked if they should pursue a third-party operator.

Delinger said exploring the option was a good idea, but not saying the city had to do it. He said Helena went through an RFP process, then felt it wasn’t right and didn’t sign an agreement.

TheatreDNA suggested that the city hire at least 1.5 more full-time equivalents and make significant improvements to the marketing since locals didn’t know about many shows.

In May, Doyon said “this is going to be a slow-moving change.”

City approves new Mansfield business model [2024]

Earlier this year, the city issued a request for proposals for third-party vendors and received three.

One was deemed incomplete and not considered.

The others were from VenuWorks and The Newberry.

Staff internally reviewed those two proposals and recommended VenuWorks then proceeded to agreement discussions with the company, which is now before commissioners for consideration.

[VenuWorks preliminary operating budget]

The proposed management scope includes room scheduling and rental sales, event booking and
promotion, marketing, ticketing and box office services, event staffing, customer service, food and
beverage services, financial administration, event settlements, and operating reports.

The city will retain ownership of the facilities, many of which are in the Civic Center, which is also the center of city government offices and services.

City developing new business model for Mansfield Theater, event spaces [2024]

If approved, the agreement includes a six-month transition period from January to July then an initial five-year agreement from July 1 through June 30, 2032 with the option to renew through 2037.

The city may terminate the agreement “for public convenience upon 90 business days’ advance written notice when the city determines termination is in its best interests. The agreement also provides for termination for default if VenuWorks fails to fulfill its contractual obligations or declares bankruptcy. If VenuWorks fails to perform its obligations, the city has the right to enter the facility and fulfil those obligations,” according to the city staff report.

City seeking grant for Mansfield Theater improvements [2022]

The city’s current budget for Civic Center events is “projected to be sufficient to cover the transition operations period,” with the city depositing $100,000 into a new operating account for initial operating expenses not covered by operating revenue and the six-month base management fee of $72,000.

The initial $100,o00 deposit is not a limit on the city’s financial obligation and is responsible for operating shortfalls under the agreement. That includes any costs that exceed the operating revenues and account funds beyond the management fee.

Under the agreement, VenuWorks would also receive a variable management fee equal to six percent of annual gross food and beverage sales actually collected, plus a monthly commission equal to 10 percent of gross cash revenue from sponsorships, display advertising, and naming rights that it directly procures during the agreement period and that the city approves in writing.

Mansfield Center still low on events, revenue due to COVID; will host some jury selection [2020]

The city does not have a citywide naming rights policy for city-owned facilities.

City officials took a TheatreDNA recommendation and for the current budget, moved Civic Center facility internal services charges, which include electricity, gas and other utilities, out of the events budget since staff couldn’t reliably separate which charges were associated with other city operations.

Under the agreement, VenuWorks would present its operations and budget during the commission’s annual budget process and commissioners retain control of the fee schedule for city-owned event facilities.

City approves $2.19 million contract for Municipal Court relocation to Missouri Room [2024]

During the Nov. 4 commission work session, Jeremy Jones, deputy city manager, said the city had struggled to balance resources and services.

He said TheatreDNA showed the city it needed a “significant shift in the business model we have operated under for the past decade or so.”

Jones said staff believes VenuWorks meets the city’s needs and its leaders said they’d work with local arts groups.

Mike Silva, VenuWorks president, said they provide a guarantee of financial transparency and that they’d spend some time studying the Great Falls market to see what works.

Chris Carton, VenuWorks’ vice president of food and beverage, said they plan to do in-house creative events such as bourbon and wine tasting dinners, wine clubs, mystery theater dinners and events that promote local sports, such as MMA and boxing.

City approves new fees for Mansfield [2019]

The long-range goal, he said, would be to bring catering completely in-house for Civic Center events and get their own liquor license for the facility, but for the short-term, they’d stay involved with local entities.

Silva said they’re a service provider but “we structure our deals so that we have skin in the game. If we are not doing the job, we are not getting paid.”

He said VenuWorks manages 70 venues nationwide, many of which are similar in size to Great Falls.

Silva said they wanted to drive revenue and reduce the city’s subsidy and to enhance and contribute to the quality of life in Great Falls, “which is exactly what those buildings were built for.”

City staff looks at options for turning Missouri Room into office space at Great Falls Civic Center [2018]

Mansfield advisory board members and symphony representatives who attended the Nov. 4 meeting told The Electric that VenuWorks told them they would not invest in facility improvements.

Carton said that for the kitchen in the Mansfield Convention Center, they would work with their vendors to get catering equipment at low to no cost.

Commissioner Rick Tryon asked about VenuWorks competing with local venues.

Silva said they would take events that didn’t fit in existing venues, focusing on those for 800-plus audiences.

Commissioner Joe McKenney said that as far as he was concerned, “the existing users are heroes,” who continued to use and support the facilities and asked what VenuWorks would do to protect them.

Silva said they typically enter into multi-year agreements with existing users or primary tenants, such as the Great Falls Symphony and Great Falls Community Concert Association, to give them first rights to the calendar, as long as they solidify their calendars by a certain date.

“We know these primary users are the backbone,” he said.

Hillary Shepherd, the symphony’s executive director, sent an email to Jeremy Jones on Nov. 5 with questions about the VenuWorks proposal. She said that as of Nov. 16, Jones had not responded.

She wrote that after speaking with the VenuWorks representatives on Nov. 4, “I am much more concerned about the symphony than I was before. My biggest concern at the moment is their lack of transparency regarding their ticketing policy. Both of them refused to answer my questions and they refused to refer me to someone in their organization who could answer my questions.”

She wrote that both Silva and Carton made comments about using Ticketmaster for all of their ticket sales and that she’s concerned they’ll force the symphony to use the same platform.

“Not only is Ticketmaster extremely cost-prohibitive for us to operate, but I also heard [Silva] admit that they get a generous cut from all of the ticketing fees collected by the platform and we would have no say over what those ticketing fees will be and they’d likely be exorbitant.”

Shepherd wrote that if VenuWorks hadn’t disclosed that agreement with Ticketmaster, it meant the city wouldn’t have access to those funds and “we would have no choice but to use a different venue. It would kill us financially to have all of our earned revenue tied up with VenuWorks for the majority of the year and it would kill all the momentum we have had over the past few years with our customer relationship management lifecycle because we will never be able to converse with our patrons when they purchase tickets with us.”

Shepherd wrote that as one of Mansfield’s major stakeholders, she needed to fully understand the financial and operational implications of the proposed agreement so the symphony could prepare for the next season.

Shepherd sent Jones a list of questions and requests that she said she’d attempted to discuss with the VenuWorks representatives the day before. Her main concern was initially ticketing, but also had concerns about their youth orchestra, theater rental costs and equipment.

Silva said they wouldn’t exceed the city’s existing budget for events for the current fiscal year, which runs through June 30, but will eventually need to increase staff to five or six, depending on revenue, and plan to do a national search for a director.

“There’s some untested waters here,” he said.

They’d all be VenuWorks employees.

Melissa Kinzler, city finance director, said the proposed VenuWorks is similar to what the city has with CourseCo for management of its two municipal golf courses.

The arrangement includes the new operating fund that holds all revenue for shows and concessions and VenuWorks would pay its own staff out of that fund and the city pays the management fee out of that fund.

If there’s a deficit, the city is responsible. Kinzler said that ideally, the city won’t need to subsidize the fund and revenues will cover expenses, similar to what happened with CourseCo.

She said they’d review financials monthly.

The CourseCo agreement currently in force includes a provision that CourseCo put $100,000 toward capital equipment and improvements over the next 10 years.

City approves golf management agreement extension [2025]

Silva said that if selected, VenuWorks would start working on Great Falls the next day and first publish the position for a director internally, then move to a national search with the hope of having someone on site Jan. 2.

They’d start the booking process on Nov. 18, he said.

Doyon said there’s office space in the Civic Center for VenuWorks’ on-site manager.

Jones said, “we feel for our community as a whole, for arts and industry, this is the best option we have to turn the system around that has not been working.”

Tryon said “we should have been doing this a long time ago.”

Commissioner Casey Schreiner said he was fine with it for now, but wanted more information on financials, particularly the expected initial investment in facilities.

He said he knows there are needs in the facilities but didn’t know if the city had money to meet them.