Pherigo sentenced in 2024 downtown assault

More than two years after an assault in a downtown alley left a man with a severe brain injury, Ethanel Pherigo was sentenced on Oct. 29 to 40 years in Montana State Prison.

As Judge John Parker announced the sentence, Pherigo’s mother stood up behind him and began to audibly sob.

After Pherigo was led out of the courtroom by deputies and jail staff, the victim’s wife walked over to Pherigo’s mother and hugged her as they both cried.

In September 2024, Pherigo and two others assaulted Jake Kraus in the alley behind City Bar downtown.

Pherigo sentencing pushed to June for 2024 downtown assault

In surveillance video shown in court and described by Great Falls Police Department Det. Travis Burow, Pherigo punched Kraus about six times and stomped on his head three times, then a fourth time after Kraus had gone limp.

Kraus’ injuries were initially believed to be fatal.

He survived, but not without months of medical care, therapy and lifelong injuries.

Pherigo was charged with robbery and aggravated assault.

In December 2024, he signed an agreement to plead guilty to the robbery charge in exchange for the prosecution dismissing the assault charge.

Parker did not suspend any of Pherigo’s sentence but did not impose a parole restriction.

He also ordered $275,000 in restitution.

Judge decides Edwards will be tried as adult in 2024 downtown assault

Pherigo’s sentencing has been delayed for more than a year and he has been held at the Cascade County Adult Detention Center since September 2024.

Pherigo was 19 at the time of the assault and is now 21.

The victim’s wife, Chrissy Kraus, and his mother, Carrie McGlynn, spoke about the impact of the attack on the victim and their family.

Pherigo’s aunt and mother spoke about the trauma he experienced as a boy.

“It’s very clear how much suffering is on the table in this room,” Parker said.

He said he took note of Pherigo’s childhood trauma and that judges have to account for the impact of trauma on someone of a young age.

“It’s not right; I wish you didn’t have to go through it,” Parker said.

The victim and his family faced “tremendous suffering,” he said.

Court considering whether juvenile involved in 2024 downtown assault should be tried as adult

Parker said what he saw in the video of Pherigo and the other two involved at a convenience store after the attack looked like a celebration of what had happened, “seems like he and his friends were doubling down on what they did in that moment.”

Parker noted a jail assault incident in August 2025 involving Pherigo, in which it looked in the video as though Pherigo continued to hit the person after he was down, similar to the attack on Kraus.

He said it was a public safety indicator that he couldn’t ignore and while he was considering rehabilitation, “what’s been put in front of me is troubling.”

Parker said that after watching the surveillance footage of the assault, it appeared Kraus had been attacked in a “mob format” and was struggling to imagine how it could happen here.

DeBerry sentenced to 40 years in 2024 downtown assault [2025]

Kraus’ wife and mother spoke of the impact to the victim’s now 6-year-old son and said, “I’m going to be carrying that with me for a long time to come.”

He said he’ll also be carrying the testimony of the tough time Pherigo had as a young boy.

Parker said he wasn’t imposing a parole restriction and, looking at the Kraus family, he said he understood they may not be happy about that, but it was his way of saying, “maybe if this man had had a little more support as a little kid, this wouldn’t have happened.”

To the Kraus family, Parker said there was “nothing this court can ever do to make it right for your family.”

As he closed the hearing, Parker said to those in the courtroom on both sides, “my heart goes out to you.”

Before Parker announced the sentence, Pherigo said “the weight of the shame I feel is equal to the weight of the world.”

When he was first incarcerated, Pherigo said he tried to distance himself from his actions and tried to blame it on addiction, anyone or anything but himself.

Pherigo sentencing delayed again in 2024 downtown assault [2025]

He said he’s young, but has “learned you can only run from yourself for so long.”

Pherigo said no one else made the choice he made that night and “Jacob Kraus for damn sure didn’t make my decisions. I was presented with a decision to make and I made the wrong one.”

To the victim, he said he was “sickeningly remorseful” and now understood the “colossal impact” of what he’d done.

“It takes a nobody to do what I did to you,” he said, and that he prayed daily for Jake Kraus’ recovery and was taking “steps to become a man that deserves your forgiveness” and “will never again be that small person who took such disturbing actions.”

During the hearing, Chrissy Kraus, the victim’s wife, said Sept. 8, 2024 was supposed to be the best day as they were celebrating her birthday at a downtown concert, but is now remembered as one of the worst days of her life.

She said her husband had been addicted to drugs as a teenager and served 10 years in prison for a crime in which no one was injured.

Deberry changes plea in 2024 downtown assault [2025]

She said he was arrested again in 2019 and was in jail while their son was born. She said she wouldn’t let Jake Kraus be around their son until he committed to treatment and recovery.

She said her husband was accountable for his actions and got his life together.

She couldn’t get ahold of him that night and on Sept. 9, 2024, was told he’d been involved in an assault and was in the ICU at Benefis Health System.

She said the police asked her to identify him by his tattoos because they hadn’t been able to identify him.

At the hospital, she found her husband on a ventilator, “lying there lifeless, it seemed.”

As a nurse, she knew the situation was dire when a trauma surgeon walked into the room.

Pherigo takes plea in downtown assault; others involved have upcoming trials [2025]

An MRI confirmed a severe brain injury and she said doctors said her husband was unlikely to survive and if he did, his quality of life would be poor.

Jake Kraus survived, but the damage was severe and he’s not the same person he was before the assault, she said.

She said that their son “has a shell of a dad now,” and to Pherigo, “you robbed my husband from me. I’m grieving the loss of my husband Jake Kraus as he sits next to me.”

Carrie McGlynn, Jake Kraus’ mother, said that Pherigo “tried his best to murder my son” and “repeatedly and viciously stomped on my son’s head.”

She said her son’s brain was “catastrophically injured” and the swelling didn’t go down until last month.

Juvenile’s charge upgraded to attempted homicide in Sept. 8 assault case [2024]

“These men murdered my son, but a miracle saved him,” McGlynn said. “Jake will struggle in so many ways for the rest of his life. I am broken in ways I doubt I will ever recover from. This is a years-long nightmare, but one there’s no waking up from. I am so deeply heartbroken.”

Serena Anderson, Pherigo’s aunt, helped raise him as her sister, Pherigo’s mother, struggled with addiction and was incarcerated.

She said she was 16 when she started helping take care of Pherigo.

Anderson said that Pherigo and his sister entered foster care when he was 4 years old and later came to live with her, sharing custody with Pherigo’s grandmother.

Two more charged in Sept. 8 assault; two women charged in connection with missing 12-year-old [2024]

He struggled and seemed lost, she said, but was enrolled in therapy at a young age.

Later, it was discovered that his sister had been abused by her father and Anderson said Pherigo believed he should have stopped it. She said she told him he was just a child when it happened, and it was the adults who failed his sister.

“He couldn’t let go of the guilt,” she said.

Eventually, Pherigo’s mother was released from prison and regained custody of him and his sister.

But, she relapsed and Pherigo started spending time on the streets and using marijuana.

Pherigo came back to Montana and seemed to improve, Anderson said, but after he moved to Great Falls, she said she noticed a change in him and in speaking with him the week before the assault, she sensed something was wrong.

When she learned of his crime, Anderson said she struggled to reconcile that the child she helped raise could be responsible for causing such pain.

“My heart ached” for the victim and his family, she said.

She didn’t ask the court to overlook his actions, “he should absolutely be held accountable,” but asked the court to consider that he needs comprehensive substance abuse and mental health treatment.

Christina Anderson, Pherigo’s mother, said that she was absent for most of his life due to substance abuse and incarceration.

Pherigo’s attorney, Levi Roadman, asked if she thought that affected him.

“In every way shape and form, yes,” she said.

Shaun Deberry and Jesse Edwards, Jr. were also charged in the assault.

Deberry was 19 at the time of the assault and Edwards was 14.

Deberry signed a plea agreement and was sentenced in December for his role in the assault to 40 years with the Montana Department of Corrections, with none suspended, a 20-year parole restriction and $709,000 in restitution.

Weekend crime roundup: man charged for stomping on man’s head in alley; man charged for carrying gun near mall; woman charged for hitting another in the head with a rock [2024]

In the agreement, he pleaded guilty to accountability for robbery.

Edwards was initially charged with felony aggravated assault in juvenile court.

Prosecutors upgraded his charge to deliberate attempted homicide and his case is still pending as Parker decided earlier this year that Edwards will be tried as an adult.